schmutz said:Queen Boo said:Ikr. I think some people consider Marching Band a sport because it involves walking and outdoors.Mariomario64 said:Marching band a sport?
what
I think I might slap you.
Walking? It's not called walking band. It's called marching band. We don't walk. If we walked our pitch would bounce all over the place anytime we weren't at a hold. We MARCH. It takes a lot more concentration than you think. Any time the band is at a move we must use a rollstep in order to keep our upper bodies still, maintaining the pitch. Except wait, it's not walking in a straight line. In our drill, we set forms that require the band to march forward, backward, left, right, crabstep, everything. You try "walking" backward on the balls of your feet in a glidestep at 60 bpm completely uniform with everyone else while trying to keep a whole note on a huge ass sousaphone steady. Most of you probably wouldn't even have the breath support for tuba or flute sitting down. Oh, did I forget the band part? Yeah, we also play as we march, seven minutes of memorized and very difficult music. Oh, wait, I forgot to mention that we also do ALL OF THIS in heavy wool uniforms and shakos. Still not convinced it's a sport?
[quote author=dictionary.com]sport: an athletic activity requiring skill or physical prowess and often of a competitive nature
Skill: check. Physical prowess: check. Competition: check.
Oh, did you think we just played at halftime and then sat and twiddled our thumbs? NOPE. We actually compete. Every other Saturday, my band hauls itself to a field where dozens of bands from southwestern Pennsylvania compete in different size classes. My school's band easily has 10 times more trophies than our football team. It's not just schools, either. Ever heard of DCI? Probably not. Drum Corps International is "professional marching band," so to speak. In fact, world finals were just last week in Indianapolis. Still not convinced? Sports Illustrated thinks it's a sport. Studies were done on Drum Corps members and found that during performances, their metabolic rates matched those of marathon runners mid-race, while their heart rate compared with someone running anywhere from a 400-800 m dash.
In conclusion, why don't you attend band camp one sweltering August and see how much we "walk."
Also: have a look.
This is Broken Arrow. They usually clean up at Bands of America. This is a high school band.
Oh, did you think we just played at halftime and then sat and twiddled our thumbs? NOPE. We actually compete. Every other Saturday, my band hauls itself to a field where dozens of bands from southwestern Pennsylvania compete in different size classes. My school's band easily has 10 times more trophies than our football team. It's not just schools, either. Ever heard of DCI? Probably not. Drum Corps International is "professional marching band," so to speak. In fact, world finals were just last week in Indianapolis. Still not convinced? Sports Illustrated thinks it's a sport. Studies were done on Drum Corps members and found that during performances, their metabolic rates matched those of marathon runners mid-race, while their heart rate compared with someone running anywhere from a 400-800 m dash.
In conclusion, why don't you attend band camp one sweltering August and see how much we "walk."
Also: have a look.
This is Broken Arrow. They usually clean up at Bands of America. This is a high school band.
inb4tl;dr
[/quote]
Amen.
I play flute for marching band. In order to have the breath support to keep those high pitch notes in tune requires so much air and very clean feet. The hardest part is that you upper body stays forward while your lower half goes in any direction, which does twist you up and affect your breathing.
Likewise to you, we don't just perform halftime but actual competitions and earn a score. We practice so much, especially during the summer. In fact, we have a week long practice called Band Camp. There is so much that goes into this sport that other sports cannot stand up to. If Bowling is a sport, than MB is too.
Also, MB requires a lot of focus and self-discipline, and a lot of time spent practicing. There is so much happening in those seven-eight minutes that many people cannot fully grasp. Feet, posture, playing, dynamics, style, balance, auxiliary, drill, articulation, et cetera.