Canon Tier list.

[3D Player 2004]

In this thread: Rank the characters based on how they would fare in combat canon-wise, not by personal preference.

1. Mario/Luigi tie
3. Bowser
4. Rosalina
5. Yoshi
6. Bowser Jr
7. Toad
8. Boo
9. Peach/Daisy tie
11. Wario/Waluigi tie

 

[Mcmadness]

Mario/Luigi/Yoshi
Bowser
The rest.

 

[Glowsquid]

In this thread: Rank the characters based on how they would fare in combat canon-wise, not by personal preference.
11. Wario/Waluigi tie

the hell, Waluigi is a CQC god

 

[DragonFreak]

9. Peach/Daisy tie

>Argues that Peach and Daisy would not be clones in SSB4
>Has same strength.

 

[Boo Diddly]

Chain Chomp, nuff said.

 

[Magikrazy]

I'll make a hierarchy list.

Rosalina
Star Spirits
Higher Star beings like ♥♪!?
Lower Star beings like Think

At this point, I'm just focusing on the Mushroom Kingdom.

Princess Peach
Toadsworth
Mario and Luigi
Toadbert
Other members of Peach's cabinet
Lower class Toads
Yoshies
Shy Guys
Koopas
Goombas

 

[Ray Trace]

Baby Luigi is a god so he'd win all battles.

Of course, Wario would be in the bottom since he would get killed so often

In this thread: Rank the characters based on how they would fare in combat canon-wise, not by personal preference.

---- that

 

[Lee Chaolan]

Invincible Star + Luigi = Problem Solved.

 

[Vommack]

>"not by personal preference"
>Wario and Waluigi at bottom
Ha. Haha. Ha.

 

[DragonFreak]

>"not by personal preference"
>Wario and Waluigi at bottom
Ha. Haha. Ha.

If anything, they should be stronger than Mario and Luigi really.

Wario especially, capable of carrying 100 treasures (some of them REALLY heavy as in Wario Land 3)

 

[3D Player 2004]

>"not by personal preference"
>Wario and Waluigi at bottom
Ha. Haha. Ha.

Well they are total idiots.

 

[Ray Trace]

Why is Boo near the bottom? He's a freaking ghost

 

[GalacticPetey]

The problem with making a tier list is unlike something like DBZ or DC comics, none of the characters really have an definable feats. Half of them only appear in sports games. There's no way to actually determine the fighting prowess and strength of these characters.

 

[Vommack]

>"not by personal preference"
>Wario and Waluigi at bottom
Ha. Haha. Ha.

Well they are total idiots.

Yeah, it's not like there was a game called Wario World where Wario went around punching the *bleep* out of huge armies of monsters or anything.

Oh wait...

 

[DragonFreak]

>"not by personal preference"
>Wario and Waluigi at bottom
Ha. Haha. Ha.

Well they are total idiots.

Idiocy ≠ fighting capabilities.

 

[Ray Trace]

The problem with making a tier list is unlike something like DBZ or DC comics, none of the characters really have an definable feats. Half of them only appear in sports games. There's no way to actually determine the fighting prowess and strength of these characters.

Canon arguments are usually one of the worst internet arguments anyway

 

[Lee Chaolan]

Favouritism plays a big part of this anyway. I mean, look at DC vs Marvel arguments. Super Man is stronger than the Hulk, no he isn't, etc. etc, etc. This is never gonna go anywhere.

 

[GalacticPetey]

Except Superman is. I'm gonna avoid this argument before it starts though.

 

[LeftyGreenMario]

Daisy
Wario
Metal Mario
Mario
Baby Luigi
Toad
Luigi
Baby Mario
Toadette
Rosalina
Everyone else
Koopa Troopa
A cockroach
Yoshi

 

[Lee Chaolan]

Except Superman is. I'm gonna avoid this argument before it starts though.

That's exactly what I mean though. Then it goes to "But the Hulk is stronger than Thor! He could easily take on an alien!" AND, then it goes to the more technical stuff and much better reasoning than I can bring out. The same is gonna happen soon here.

 

[LeftyGreenMario]

>"not by personal preference"
>Wario and Waluigi at bottom
Ha. Haha. Ha.

Well they are total idiots.

I put Wario in the top of my tier list, just underneath Daisy, because nobody would want to approach Wario with a 10 meter stick. Second, his fat absorbs all blows, including giant missiles.

 

[Vommack]

>"not by personal preference"
>Wario and Waluigi at bottom
Ha. Haha. Ha.

Well they are total idiots.

I put Wario in the top of my tier list, just underneath Daisy, because nobody would want to approach Wario with a 10 meter stick. Second, his fat absorbs all blows, including giant missiles.

So, why's Daisy at th-
*double dash flashback*
...Right, not gonna question that.

 

[LeftyGreenMario]

>"not by personal preference"
>Wario and Waluigi at bottom
Ha. Haha. Ha.

Well they are total idiots.

I put Wario in the top of my tier list, just underneath Daisy, because nobody would want to approach Wario with a 10 meter stick. Second, his fat absorbs all blows, including giant missiles.

So, why's Daisy at th-
*double dash flashback*
...Right, not gonna question that.

It's not that.

She's just indestructible and the only thing that can restore order to Mushroom Kingdom after an onslaught of Wario.

 

[Vommack]

It's not that.

She's just indestructible and the only thing that can restore order to Mushroom Kingdom after an onslaught of Wario.

..uh, you're sure this is canon and not some kind of twisted fanfic?

 

[Ray Trace]

It's not that.

She's just indestructible and the only thing that can restore order to Mushroom Kingdom after an onslaught of Wario.

..uh, you're sure this is canon and not some kind of twisted fanfic?

Twisted headcanons