That doesn't sound like a bad idea honestly. I already have a plan to watch list but it's more so a 'this show looks mildly interesting, on the list it goes' than a 'I am going to watch this soon because I want to' list.
There were about 50 that I took an interest in but I pushed it down to these.
only 25, I have 200 or so to choose from. Also, in no particular order.
(01)Aiura
(02)Anohana: The Flower We Saw That Day
(03)Kokoro Connect
(04)Steins;Gate
(05)Psycho-Pass
(06)Bakuman.
(07)Welcome to N.H.K.
(08)Working!!
(09)Kino's Journey
(10)Samurai Champloo
(11)Cencoroll
(12)Code Geass
(13)Cowboy Bebop
(14)Darker than Black
(15)The Severing Crime Edge
(16)Paranoia Agent
(17)Durarara!!
(18)Horizon in the Middle of Nowhere
(19)Kyousougiga (TV)
(20)Sword of the Stranger
(21)Girls und Panzer
(22)Kara no Kyoukai
(23)Eden of the East
(24)Penguindrum
(25)K-On!
(01)Aiura
(02)Anohana: The Flower We Saw That Day
(03)Kokoro Connect
(04)Steins;Gate
(05)Psycho-Pass
(06)Bakuman.
(07)Welcome to N.H.K.
(08)Working!!
(09)Kino's Journey
(10)Samurai Champloo
(11)Cencoroll
(12)Code Geass
(13)Cowboy Bebop
(14)Darker than Black
(15)The Severing Crime Edge
(16)Paranoia Agent
(17)Durarara!!
(18)Horizon in the Middle of Nowhere
(19)Kyousougiga (TV)
(20)Sword of the Stranger
(21)Girls und Panzer
(22)Kara no Kyoukai
(23)Eden of the East
(24)Penguindrum
(25)K-On!
There were about 50 that I took an interest in but I pushed it down to these.