Overrated Mario Characters (besides Yoshi)

Who do you think is the most overrated Mario Character?

  • Mario

    Votes: 7 11.9%

  • Luigi

    Votes: 6 10.2%

  • Fawful

    Votes: 7 11.9%

  • Rosalina

    Votes: 4 6.8%

  • The babies

    Votes: 2 3.4%

  • Toad

    Votes: 3 5.1%

  • Peach

    Votes: 3 5.1%

  • Waluigi

    Votes: 1 1.7%

  • Bowser Jr.

    Votes: 3 5.1%

  • Koopalings

    Votes: 3 5.1%

  • Geno

    Votes: 20 33.9%
  • Total voters
    59
Re: Overrated Mario Characters

Pinkie Pie said:
Err... he is... he's the third choice under Mario and Luigi...
Click to expand...

Oh. Well, then...this is...um...
 
Re: Overrated Mario Characters

Alright fine. I'll add Waluigi later.
 
Re: Overrated Mario Characters

I like Waluigi more than Luigi but then I like Mario over Wario. Waluigi has the amount of fans I was expecting from him so he is not underrated or overrated.
 
Re: Overrated Mario Characters

Added Waluigi. Also removed Daisy because

1. Nobody voted for her.
2. She probably wouldn't be considered overrated anyway.
 
Re: Overrated Mario Characters

Why isn't Yoshi on the list? He is massively overrated by his fans. For me, he's a real stinker. Yoshi would be my first choice x32490. D:<

EDIT:Otherwise, I voted for the Koopalings. Some of their fans are not intelligent, and I don't understand why the evil teenagers get so much praise.

EDIT:Sorry, Mario isn't overrated. He's underrated in fact. I think he's one of the most underrated characters along with Daisy and Waluigi. Too many fans just kick him around and roll him in dirt. I know Nintendo treats him like a god, but the fans are just... "die Mario!" Others say he is a boring thing. No, since I grew up with him, I find him to be a happy guy and he is far from a personality-less robot, thanks to Charles Martinet.
 
Re: Overrated Mario Characters

I don't know why people voted for Mario. In the world of Mario fans, Mario is often treated...like garbage.
 
Re: Overrated Mario Characters

Ornithologist Mario said:
I don't know why people voted for Mario. In the world of Mario fans, Mario is often treated...like garbage.
Click to expand...

Ugh...tell me about it. I used go to this website for koopaling fans and you would not believe the crap Mario goes through.
 
Re: Overrated Mario Characters

Yes, exactly. Why are so many Koopaling fans irrational? Sometimes, I dislike a character just because of the fanbase. If the fans weren't inconsiderate zealots, I would be at most neutral to them.

The babies are underrated, too. Many people hate them when they are included in a Mario Kart, but when characters like Metal Mario is introduced, it's all bells and whistles? I don't understand, but this is going off-topic.
 
Re: Overrated Mario Characters

@LGM's Yoshi hate: dammit did any of you read the fourth line of the opening post
 
Re: Overrated Mario Characters

Yes, I did, but I was to lazy to change my post.
 
Re: Overrated Mario Characters

Fair enough.
 
Re: Overrated Mario Characters

Sometimes, the activity on this forum is like a hilariously bad sitcom.

Anyway, I think out of all the Koopalings, Lemmy gets the most attention (he's the mascot of the koopaling fan site I mentioned earlier). But I can't really blame anyone. After all, he balances on his Circus ball making him look more psychically more unique than the other koopalings.
 
Re: Overrated Mario Characters

I admit, Fawful is quite overrated. I don't find any appeal in him. The fans aren't so bad, unless I'm spending too little time on other places.
 
Re: Overrated Mario Characters

Ornithologist Mario said:
I admit, Fawful is quite overrated. I don't find any appeal in him. The fans aren't so bad, unless I'm spending too little time on other places.
Click to expand...

Yeah he's also quite overrated. Not as overrated as Geno, but still overrated, in general.
 
Re: Overrated Mario Characters

Geno deserves all these votes.

He is only there in one game, but fans keep screaming for him.
 
Re: Overrated Mario Characters

I am a bit surprised no one voted for Rosalina. I am quite fond of Rosalina myself, but her fanbase is quite big for a character who had a major role in only one game.
 
Re: Overrated Mario Characters

Probably because the other characters are more overrated than her.

Mario or Toad aren't more overrated than her. :(
 
Re: Overrated Mario Characters

But I do agree that Geno deserves the most votes. He's just some silly puppet in my eyes.
 
Re: Overrated Mario Characters

Baby Luigi said:
I am a bit surprised no one voted for Rosalina. I am quite fond of Rosalina myself, but her fanbase is quite big for a character who had a major role in only one game.
Click to expand...

Rosalina's fan base is a lot less ridiculous than what the Geno and Fawful fans are capable of spawning. At least, I think that's the case.
 
Re: Overrated Mario Characters

I agree. ^ Definitely.

People love Rosalina, but not in a zealous way.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back