Your Dream Roster

[UltraMario]

did you bump this just to troll bronies

you make me sick

edit: plus not a word in this thread was even spoken of ponies

 

[MikeyO11]

I didn't mean that, but it's the TRUTH.

 

[Magikrazy]

Name one person who even thinks that's a decent idea.

 

[MikeyO11]

Search up SSB4 or Super Smash Bros. Universe on DeviantArt. You might find something.

 

[Pyro]

>deviantart

HAH

 

[Cirdec]

Search up SSB4 or Super Smash Bros. Universe on DeviantArt. You might find something.

Everyone here knows ponies would never appear.

 

[PrincessOfPeaches]

Mario
Luigi
Peach
Bowser
Bowser Jr.

Donkey Kong
Diddy Kong
Dixie Kong
King K. Rool

Wario

Yoshi
Baby Bros.

Link
Zelda/Sheik
Ganondorf
Toon Link (Only if he's not a clone of Link)
Toon Zelda/Tetra (Only if she's not a clone of Zelda)

Samus/Zero Suit Samus
Sylux

Kirby
Meta Knight
King Dedede
Bandana Waddle Dee

Pit
Palutena

R.O.B

Olimar

Pikachu
Jigglypuff
2nd generation Pokemon Trainer (Chikorita-Quilava-Feraligatr)
Lucario
Zoroark

Fox
Falco
Wolf
Krystal

Marth
Ike
Lyn

Lucas
Ness
Porky

Captain Falcon
Samurai Goroh

Mr. Game and Watch

Ice Climbers

Tom Nook

The Punch Out!!! series
Little Mac

The Ballon Fight series
Ballon Fighter

 

[BowserJunior]

Just gonna list newcomers:

Mario: Bowser Jr.

Zelda: Girahim

Kirby: Bandanna Dee

Pokemon: new Pokemon for Pokemon trainer

Yoshi: Baby Mario, maybe w/baby Luigi.

Fire Emblem: Chrom

F-Zero: Goroh

3P: Mega Man

 

[Fawfulthegreat64]

Now that this has been bumped, I'll go ahead and list my "dream" roster. Note that this is only my dream roster and is almost definitely not going to happen.

Add Fawful.

Don't care what is added/deleted from any other franchises, (I'm not even familiar enough to say my preferences on them). Before you start bashing me, read the title of the thread, because I just know someone will bash me about this.

 

[Ray Trace]

My dream roster contains Baby Mario, Baby Luigi, Toadette, Ness, Wario, Donkey Kong, Captain Falcon, and Ganondorf. That's it. You can add anyone else; I don't care.

 

[supermariofan]

Bowser Jr
Waluigi

King K Rool

Vaati
Impa
Ghirahim

Bandana Dee

Mewtwo
Zoroark
6th gen rep

Ridley

Krystal

Claus

Shulk
Isaac
Saki

Little Mac
Takamaru
Duck Hunt Dog

Palutena

Megaman
Pac-Man
Rayman
Layton
Sora

Chrom
Lyn

Everyone stays except Lucario and Toon Link

 

[New Super Mario]

OK, I'm critiquing.

I assume you only put additions on?

Bowser Jr
Waluigi (Mario only needs 5 reps, I think, and out of these Bowser Jr. makes more sense. Even though I think Toad is a better choice)

King K Rool

Vaati
Impa
Ghirahim (as much as I love Zelda, that's too many reps. Just Ghirahim is fine.)

Bandana Dee

Mewtwo
Zoroark
6th gen rep (I don't care about pokemon as long as there is no pokemon trainer)

Ridley

Krystal (Star Fox, I don't think needs a fourth rep. They haven't had a game in a long time)

Claus (eh, no)

Shulk
Isaac
Saki (I just don't see the bottom two happening, really)

Little Mac
Takamaru
Duck Hunt Dog (We've been over this.)

Palutena

Megaman
Pac-Man
Rayman
Layton
Sora (WAY TO MANY THIRD PARTIES. 3 at the most. But I'm cutting 3 and only keeping two since they don't seem unlikely. I think Sonic might return anyway)

Chrom
Lyn (I don't care what people think. If you've played Fire Emblem, you know how awful of a pick she is. As long as they keep Marth and Ike, and add Chrom, it will be perfect)

Everyone stays except Lucario and Toon Link (I actually don't mind this)

 

[Fawfulthegreat64]

Waluigi

I'd love to see Waluigi.

 

[supermariofan]

OK, I'm critiquing.

I assume you only put additions on?

Bowser Jr
Waluigi (Mario only needs 5 reps, I think, and out of these Bowser Jr. makes more sense. Even though I think Toad is a better choice)

King K Rool

Vaati
Impa
Ghirahim (as much as I love Zelda, that's too many reps. Just Ghirahim is fine.)

Bandana Dee

Mewtwo
Zoroark
6th gen rep (I don't care about pokemon as long as there is no pokemon trainer)

Ridley

Krystal (Star Fox, I don't think needs a fourth rep. They haven't had a game in a long time)

Claus (eh, no)

Shulk
Isaac
Saki (I just don't see the bottom two happening, really)

Little Mac
Takamaru
Duck Hunt Dog (We've been over this.)

Palutena

Megaman
Pac-Man
Rayman
Layton
Sora (WAY TO MANY THIRD PARTIES. 3 at the most. But I'm cutting 3 and only keeping two since they don't seem unlikely. I think Sonic might return anyway)

Chrom
Lyn (I don't care what people think. If you've played Fire Emblem, you know how awful of a pick she is. As long as they keep Marth and Ike, and add Chrom, it will be perfect)

Everyone stays except Lucario and Toon Link (I actually don't mind this)

Why did you randomly mention Sonic? Of course he's returning, why do people always mention Snake and Sonic like they're newcomers?! They might as well mention the other veterans as well

 

[New Super Mario]

OK, I'm critiquing.

I assume you only put additions on?

Bowser Jr
Waluigi (Mario only needs 5 reps, I think, and out of these Bowser Jr. makes more sense. Even though I think Toad is a better choice)

King K Rool

Vaati
Impa
Ghirahim (as much as I love Zelda, that's too many reps. Just Ghirahim is fine.)

Bandana Dee

Mewtwo
Zoroark
6th gen rep (I don't care about pokemon as long as there is no pokemon trainer)

Ridley

Krystal (Star Fox, I don't think needs a fourth rep. They haven't had a game in a long time)

Claus (eh, no)

Shulk
Isaac
Saki (I just don't see the bottom two happening, really)

Little Mac
Takamaru
Duck Hunt Dog (We've been over this.)

Palutena

Megaman
Pac-Man
Rayman
Layton
Sora (WAY TO MANY THIRD PARTIES. 3 at the most. But I'm cutting 3 and only keeping two since they don't seem unlikely. I think Sonic might return anyway)

Chrom
Lyn (I don't care what people think. If you've played Fire Emblem, you know how awful of a pick she is. As long as they keep Marth and Ike, and add Chrom, it will be perfect)

Everyone stays except Lucario and Toon Link (I actually don't mind this)

Why did you randomly mention Sonic? Of course he's returning, why do people always mention Snake and Sonic like they're newcomers?! They might as well mention the other veterans as well

I mentioned it because only 3 third parties are needed so I chose him over Snake. (with your people anyway)

 

[supermariofan]

OK, I'm critiquing.

I assume you only put additions on?

Bowser Jr
Waluigi (Mario only needs 5 reps, I think, and out of these Bowser Jr. makes more sense. Even though I think Toad is a better choice)

King K Rool

Vaati
Impa
Ghirahim (as much as I love Zelda, that's too many reps. Just Ghirahim is fine.)

Bandana Dee

Mewtwo
Zoroark
6th gen rep (I don't care about pokemon as long as there is no pokemon trainer)

Ridley

Krystal (Star Fox, I don't think needs a fourth rep. They haven't had a game in a long time)

Claus (eh, no)

Shulk
Isaac
Saki (I just don't see the bottom two happening, really)

Little Mac
Takamaru
Duck Hunt Dog (We've been over this.)

Palutena

Megaman
Pac-Man
Rayman
Layton
Sora (WAY TO MANY THIRD PARTIES. 3 at the most. But I'm cutting 3 and only keeping two since they don't seem unlikely. I think Sonic might return anyway)

Chrom
Lyn (I don't care what people think. If you've played Fire Emblem, you know how awful of a pick she is. As long as they keep Marth and Ike, and add Chrom, it will be perfect)

Everyone stays except Lucario and Toon Link (I actually don't mind this)

Why did you randomly mention Sonic? Of course he's returning, why do people always mention Snake and Sonic like they're newcomers?! They might as well mention the other veterans as well

I mentioned it because only 3 third parties are needed so I chose him over Snake. (with your people anyway)

What I mean is why is it necessary for people to mention the characters in the previous game like they're newcomers, but they don't mention the other veterans as well?

 

[Ray Trace]

I don't even know why some of you critique other's rosters: hello, it's a DREAM roster?

 

[Smashley]

haven't most people said that they're ok with critique anyway? if you don't agree with it, you can just keep things the way you had them.

 

[Ray Trace]

I know, but critiquing kinda defeats the whole purpose of this thread

 

[New Super Mario]

I know, but critiquing kinda defeats the whole purpose of this thread

Just sharing my opinions, is all.

 

[KingMario128]

Here my list:

Spoiler

-Mario
-Luigi
-Peach
-Bowser
-Bowser Jr. or Rosalina (I can´t decide)

-Donkey Kong
-Diddy Kong

-Yoshi

-Link
-Zelda
-Ganondorf
-Toon Link
-Toon Zelda/Tetra
-Ghirahim or Vaati

-Samus/Zero Suit Samus
-Ridley

-Kirby
-King Dedede
-Meta Knight (alt Galacta Knight)
-Bandana Waddle Dee

-Pikachu
-Jigglypuff
-Pokemon Trainer Jotho (With Chikorita, Quilava and Feraligatr...or some diferent evolutions of the three)
-Mewtwo/Mewtwo Game Cube (The new mewtwo form)
-Lucario or Zoroark (Possible Lucario being replace for Zoroark but no so much)

-Fox
-Falco
-Wolf
-Krystal

-Ice Climbers

-Pit
-Magnus

-Wario
-Mona
-Young Cricket
-Ashely (I love her and i want her so much )

-Chrom
-Marth with New Desing (alt Traditional Marth)
-Ike

-Lucas
-Ness
-Masked Man
-Chuck Norris...i mean...Flint

-Olimar
-Louie

-Captain Falcon

-Mr. Game & Watch

-ROB
Other
-Issac (Golden Sun)
-Takamaru (Nazo no Murasame Jō)
-Pac-Man (Pacman/NamcoBandai Mascot)
-Little Mac (Punch Out!!)
-Megaman (Megaman/Capcom ex-mascot...very improbable)

-Snake (maybe will leave because Metal Gear lack in Nintendo recent consoles)

-Sonic


The Grand Total is: 55 Spaces in the roster/menu selection

 

[supermariofan]

Here my list:

Spoiler

-Mario
-Luigi
-Peach
-Bowser
-Bowser Jr. or Rosalina (I can´t decide) Bowser Jr is more recurring

-Donkey Kong
-Diddy KongVery rarely do I see people not put King K Rool in

-Yoshi

-Link
-Zelda
-Ganondorf
-Toon Link
-Toon Zelda/Tetra
-Ghirahim or Vaati First of all, having 5 Mario and Pokémon but 6 Zelda makes no sense, second it's your list you decide (preferably Ghirahim

-Samus/Zero Suit Samus
-Ridley Fine

-Kirby
-King Dedede
-Meta Knight (alt Galacta Knight)
-Bandana Waddle Dee Fine

-Pikachu
-Jigglypuff
-Pokemon Trainer Jotho (With Chikorita, Quilava and Feraligatr...or some diferent evolutions of the three)
-Mewtwo/Mewtwo Game Cube (The new mewtwo form)
-Lucario or Zoroark (Possible Lucario being replace for Zoroark but no so much) Okay I guess

-Fox
-Falco
-Wolf
-Krystal AWESOME!!!!

-Ice Climbers

-Pit
-Magnus You mean that guy who only shows up in the second act? I go with Palutena

-Wario
-Mona
-Young Cricket
-Ashely (I love her and i want her so much ) Uhhhhh... I thought seeing one new Wario character was weird enough but you have A LOT! Some of them are not even well known

-Chrom
-Marth with New Desing (alt Traditional Marth)
-Ike Fine

-Lucas
-Ness
-Masked Man
-Chuck Norris...i mean...Flint Only one new Mother rep (Obviously Claus)

-Olimar
-Louie Good luck with an original moveset

-Captain Falcon

-Mr. Game & Watch

-ROB
Other
-Issac (Golden Sun)
-Takamaru (Nazo no Murasame Jō)
-Pac-Man (Pacman/NamcoBandai Mascot)
-Little Mac (Punch Out!!)
-Megaman (Megaman/Capcom ex-mascot...very improbable) Fine

-Snake (maybe will leave because Metal Gear lack in Nintendo recent consoles)

-Sonic


The Grand Total is: 55 Spaces in the roster/menu selection

I'd give this roster a 4/10 mainly because you overrepped some franchises that don't need to be represented that much like Wario, and Mother

 

[yoshidude99]

Here my list:

Spoiler

-Mario
-Luigi
-Peach
-Bowser
-Bowser Jr. or Rosalina (I can´t decide) Bowser Jr is more recurring

-Donkey Kong
-Diddy KongVery rarely do I see people not put King K Rool in

-Yoshi

-Link
-Zelda
-Ganondorf
-Toon Link
-Toon Zelda/Tetra
-Ghirahim or Vaati First of all, having 5 Mario and Pokémon but 6 Zelda makes no sense, second it's your list you decide (preferably Ghirahim

-Samus/Zero Suit Samus
-Ridley Fine

-Kirby
-King Dedede
-Meta Knight (alt Galacta Knight)
-Bandana Waddle Dee Fine

-Pikachu
-Jigglypuff
-Pokemon Trainer Jotho (With Chikorita, Quilava and Feraligatr...or some diferent evolutions of the three)
-Mewtwo/Mewtwo Game Cube (The new mewtwo form)
-Lucario or Zoroark (Possible Lucario being replace for Zoroark but no so much) Okay I guess

-Fox
-Falco
-Wolf
-Krystal AWESOME!!!!

-Ice Climbers

-Pit
-Magnus You mean that guy who only shows up in the second act? I go with Palutena

-Wario
-Mona
-Young Cricket
-Ashely (I love her and i want her so much ) Uhhhhh... I thought seeing one new Wario character was weird enough but you have A LOT! Some of them are not even well known

-Chrom
-Marth with New Desing (alt Traditional Marth)
-Ike Fine

-Lucas
-Ness
-Masked Man
-Chuck Norris...i mean...Flint Only one new Mother rep (Obviously Claus)

-Olimar
-Louie Good luck with an original moveset

-Captain Falcon

-Mr. Game & Watch

-ROB
Other
-Issac (Golden Sun)
-Takamaru (Nazo no Murasame Jō)
-Pac-Man (Pacman/NamcoBandai Mascot)
-Little Mac (Punch Out!!)
-Megaman (Megaman/Capcom ex-mascot...very improbable) Fine

-Snake (maybe will leave because Metal Gear lack in Nintendo recent consoles)

-Sonic


The Grand Total is: 55 Spaces in the roster/menu selection

I'd give this roster a 4/10 mainly because you overrepped some franchises that don't need to be represented that much like Wario, and Mother

Like Baby Luigi said

I don't even know why some of you critique other's rosters: hello, it's a DREAM roster?

 

[BowserJunior]

And like smasher replied:

haven't most people said that they're ok with critique anyway? if you don't agree with it, you can just keep things the way you had them.

 

[Smashley]

(actually now i kind of agree with her in way; unless the person says its fine, critique probably would be better in that persons thread if they had one)