User Total Drama Island (Smasher Wins!)

Re: User Total Drama Island (Challenge 5: Cooking: Judges Needed!)

ChaoticLeo said:
If toad is a judge, then make sure it is annon who's food is whos.
Click to expand...
Well, duh.

Also, my Pikmin curse didn't really work anyway, so I've kinda gotten over it.
 
Re: User Total Drama Island (Challenge 5: Cooking: Judges Needed!)

we could have 4 judges

just to be entirely fair
 
Re: User Total Drama Island (Challenge 5: Cooking: Judges Needed!)

Well, on Chopped, all the judges come to a consensus together. Having an even number won't cause a tie, since the vote has to be unanimous anyway.
 
Re: User Total Drama Island (Challenge 5: Cooking)

HAVE THE CONTESTANTS JUDGE THEMSELVES
 
Re: User Total Drama Island (Challenge 5: Cooking)

Actually, nabber makes a good point.

We could have each player on each team judge each other's food. Everyone will be sent a PM of all the choices everyone else sent, and they would select from one of the two choices in each category, which would be anonymous. Then, when everyone's vote was decided, whoever got the most votes would win that category, and whichever team won the most categories would be immune for the week!

Then again, they could PM their teammates on which choice they made. Then then again, they could PM the judges and that anyways, so that basically cancels that out.

You should definitely do that!
 
Re: User Total Drama Island (Challenge 5: Cooking)

BMB said:
Actually, nabber makes a good point.

We could have each player on each team judge each other's food. Everyone will be sent a PM of all the choices everyone else sent, and they would select from one of the two choices in each category, which would be anonymous. Then, when everyone's vote was decided, whoever got the most votes would win that category, and whichever team won the most categories would be immune for the week!

Then again, they could PM their teammates on which choice they made. Then then again, they could PM the judges and that anyways, so that basically cancels that out.

You should definitely do that!
Click to expand...
Alright, I'll do that instead.
 
Re: User Total Drama Island (Challenge 5: Cooking)

New Super Mario said:
BMB said:
Actually, nabber makes a good point.

We could have each player on each team judge each other's food. Everyone will be sent a PM of all the choices everyone else sent, and they would select from one of the two choices in each category, which would be anonymous. Then, when everyone's vote was decided, whoever got the most votes would win that category, and whichever team won the most categories would be immune for the week!

Then again, they could PM their teammates on which choice they made. Then then again, they could PM the judges and that anyways, so that basically cancels that out.

You should definitely do that!
Click to expand...
Alright, I'll do that instead.
Click to expand...

Doggamnit, BMB.
 
Re: User Total Drama Island (Challenge 5: Cooking)

New Super Mario said:
BMB said:
Actually, nabber makes a good point.

We could have each player on each team judge each other's food. Everyone will be sent a PM of all the choices everyone else sent, and they would select from one of the two choices in each category, which would be anonymous. Then, when everyone's vote was decided, whoever got the most votes would win that category, and whichever team won the most categories would be immune for the week!

Then again, they could PM their teammates on which choice they made. Then then again, they could PM the judges and that anyways, so that basically cancels that out.

You should definitely do that!
Click to expand...
Alright, I'll do that instead.
Click to expand...
Though perhaps you could wait for the opinion of other people before going with it... I'm Switzerland in this, so stand by for other users.
 
Re: User Total Drama Island (Challenge 5: Cooking)

GreenDisaster said:
New Super Mario said:
BMB said:
Actually, nabber makes a good point.

We could have each player on each team judge each other's food. Everyone will be sent a PM of all the choices everyone else sent, and they would select from one of the two choices in each category, which would be anonymous. Then, when everyone's vote was decided, whoever got the most votes would win that category, and whichever team won the most categories would be immune for the week!

Then again, they could PM their teammates on which choice they made. Then then again, they could PM the judges and that anyways, so that basically cancels that out.

You should definitely do that!
Click to expand...
Alright, I'll do that instead.
Click to expand...
Though perhaps you could wait for the opinion of other people before going with it... I'm Switzerland in this, so stand by for other users.
Click to expand...
Yeah, we'll say what they say.
 
Re: User Total Drama Island (Challenge 5: Cooking)

I like the original idea better, personally.
 
Re: User Total Drama Island (Challenge 5: Cooking)

Smasher said:
I like the original idea better, personally.
Click to expand...
 
Re: User Total Drama Island (Challenge 5: Cooking)

i agree

gp, sue me later
 
Re: User Total Drama Island (Challenge 5: Cooking)

Can we continue now?
 
Re: User Total Drama Island (Challenge 5: Cooking)

you were supposed to send before we even got the judges set up

that's what i did at least
 
Re: User Total Drama Island (Challenge 5: Cooking)

Red Barchetta said:
wait, are we sending in now?
Click to expand...
Yes! Sorry if I didn't make that clear before! But as the rules state, most challenges are in the thread and will not involve too much PMs.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back