Mafia Tiering Discussion Thread

[Superchao]

No, I distinctly remember from the quicktopics. You told the wolves who was on the mafia AND you told the mafia who was on the wolves.

of course your priorities could change in two years

 

[Garlic Man]

if you could link, that'd be great

and we should probably discuss this else where (if anywhere at all), since it's off-topic

you mod you, get yourself in line

 

[NSY]

You know it's against the rules to tell the mods what to do.

Anyway Blocky is right you know.

 

[RandomYoshi]

I'm pretty sure it was intended as a joke, NSY.

 

[NSY]

Yeah.

Also like someone else said you should do a tier list.

 

[Smg2daisy]

So, is the list done?

 

[RandomYoshi]

I completely forgot about making one. X_x

 

[Smg2daisy]

*shoots RY*

*RY explodes*

 

[Time Turner]

He was the Mafia Godfather!

 

[EctoBiologist]

I hope I become god tier.

*shot*

 

[EctoBiologist]

soooooooo how it's goin'

 

[Smashley]

you know he doesn't have to make one, right?

 

[EctoBiologist]

you know he doesn't have to make one, right?

I thought he was on it.

 

[RandomYoshi]

Yeah, but I need to play more games to create a decent list. I have yet to be correctly suspected by everyone, I have yet to correctly suspect everyone, I have yet to buss everyone, etc.

Also, I need to see everyone's Day game to actually make a passable list.

And I think I also need to not actually play in a few games to see how well you all successfully scumhunt (no, you can't scumhunt by claiming in PMs. You have to do it in the thread for it to count) without sheeping me.

Also, I haven't even been challenged by some players. Come on, attack me all you want, try to get me to slip up as Scum, try to make me squirm, and don't be afraid to call me out on any scummy behaviour. I'm not automatically Town in every game, you know. You can't expect me having the Town's best interest in mind all the time.

 

[Rocker64]

Also, I haven't even been challenged by some players. Come on, attack me all you want, try to get me to slip up as Scum, try to make me squirm, and don't be afraid to call me out on any scummy behaviour. I'm not automatically Town in every game, you know. You can't expect me having the Town's best interest in mind all the time.

I have been.

Because you were scummy as all hell in sonic mafia. But nobody cared. (I know you were a confirmed innocent, but whatever.)

 

[Baby Mario Bloops]

Also, I haven't even been challenged by some players. Come on, attack me all you want, try to get me to slip up as Scum, try to make me squirm, and don't be afraid to call me out on any scummy behaviour. I'm not automatically Town in every game, you know. You can't expect me having the Town's best interest in mind all the time.

It's hard when you are like "sheep me", and you try to lynch the person going against you...

 

[Tyrell Badd]

I don't see what all the complaining is about sheeping. If you don't sheep, everyone will think you're scum. It's a lose/lose situation.

 

[Master Crash]

Also, I haven't even been challenged by some players. Come on, attack me all you want, try to get me to slip up as Scum, try to make me squirm, and don't be afraid to call me out on any scummy behaviour. I'm not automatically Town in every game, you know. You can't expect me having the Town's best interest in mind all the time.

Ooh, ooh, I did this a couple of times!

 

[Hobbes]

I don't see what all the complaining is about sheeping. If you don't sheep, everyone will think you're scum. It's a lose/lose situation.

That's something I've always hated.

 

[Specific Neptune]

Also, I haven't even been challenged by some players. Come on, attack me all you want, try to get me to slip up as Scum, try to make me squirm, and don't be afraid to call me out on any scummy behaviour. I'm not automatically Town in every game, you know. You can't expect me having the Town's best interest in mind all the time.

seriously

all this does is make the innocents suspect me, and they go all out and vote

 

[Time Turner]

Also, I haven't even been challenged by some players. Come on, attack me all you want, try to get me to slip up as Scum, try to make me squirm, and don't be afraid to call me out on any scummy behaviour. I'm not automatically Town in every game, you know. You can't expect me having the Town's best interest in mind all the time.

Yeah, and how many people have you tried to lynch for not agreeing with you?

 

[Cirdec]

Also, I haven't even been challenged by some players. Come on, attack me all you want, try to get me to slip up as Scum, try to make me squirm, and don't be afraid to call me out on any scummy behaviour. I'm not automatically Town in every game, you know. You can't expect me having the Town's best interest in mind all the time.

I did this in Forum's Choice Mafia but nobody believed me and they voted me.

 

[RandomYoshi]

Also, I haven't even been challenged by some players. Come on, attack me all you want, try to get me to slip up as Scum, try to make me squirm, and don't be afraid to call me out on any scummy behaviour. I'm not automatically Town in every game, you know. You can't expect me having the Town's best interest in mind all the time.

Yeah, and how many people have you tried to lynch for not agreeing with you?

Too many, I'll admit. But if someone actually provides a decent reason why they're disagreeing with me, I won't try to lynch that person.

Also, I haven't even been challenged by some players. Come on, attack me all you want, try to get me to slip up as Scum, try to make me squirm, and don't be afraid to call me out on any scummy behaviour. I'm not automatically Town in every game, you know. You can't expect me having the Town's best interest in mind all the time.

I did this in Forum's Choice Mafia but nobody believed me and they voted me.

I was scum in that game, and I didn't want my ass being lynched. Simple logic is simple.

 

[Time Turner]

Also, I haven't even been challenged by some players. Come on, attack me all you want, try to get me to slip up as Scum, try to make me squirm, and don't be afraid to call me out on any scummy behaviour. I'm not automatically Town in every game, you know. You can't expect me having the Town's best interest in mind all the time.

I did this in Forum's Choice Mafia but nobody believed me and they voted me.

I was scum in that game, and I didn't want my ass being lynched. Simple logic is simple.

This ended up getting both you and MCD killed. Not your finest move...

 

[MCS]

D tier
PTR
Neptune
MCS
Rin
Others

I'm in the D tier? what is this

This was a few months ago, though, so I assume I've gone up a letter or so.