Unimplemented Proposals

Ray Trace

Ray Trace

The fastest, strongest, and kindest Protector
Poll Committee
Retired Wiki Staff
Pronouns
She/her
MarioWiki
Ray Trace
Decided to make a topic about it here to bring some more attention and discussion surrounding the currently unimplemented proposals. Some aren't carried out since 2015 and honestly that's the main reason I decided to make this topic.

#ProposalsUserTime Passed
1.Create separate articles for DKC series and DKL series boss levels (MarioWiki:Proposals/Archive_41#Create_separate_articles_for_DKC_series_and_DKL_series_boss_levels)Aokage (User:Aokage)
January 3, 2015​
2.Create a template for the Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door badge drop rates (MarioWiki:Proposals/Archive_45#Create_a_template_for_the_TTYD_badge_drop_rates)Lord Bowser (User:Lord Bowser)
August 17, 2016​
3.Clean up species categories to only include non-hostile species (MarioWiki:Proposals/Archive_47#Do_Something_With_Game-Specific_Species_Categories)Niiue (User:Niiue)
August 8, 2017​
4.Clean up Category:Artifacts (Category_talk:Artifacts#Do_something_with_this_category)Niiue (User:Niiue)
August 22, 2017​
5.Trim down Category:Fire Creatures and Category:Ice Creatures (Category_talk:Ice_Creatures#Do_something_about_this_category)Doc von Schmeltwick (User:Doc von Schmeltwick)
September 7, 2017​
6.Expand the Behemoth King article (Talk:Behemoth#Merge_Behemoth_King_to_Behemoth_or_expand_Behemoth_King_article)Owencrazyboy9 (User:Owencrazyboy9)
December 23, 2017​
7.Create articles on the Remix 10 secret courses in Super Mario Run (MarioWiki:Proposals/Archive_50#The_Secret_Courses_of_Remix_10_in_Super_Mario_Run)Time Turner (User:Time Turner)
December 26, 2017​
8.Add anchor links to Power Moon lists (MarioWiki:Proposals/Archive_50#Add_anchor_links_to_Power_Moon_lists)Super Radio (User:Super Radio)
December 31, 2017​
9.Create articles for the Wario: Master of Disguise episodes (MarioWiki:Proposals/Archive_50#Give_the_Wario:_Master_of_Disguise_episodes_their_own_pages)DKPetey99 (User:DKPetey99)
January 23, 2018​
10.Merge the specified Super Smash Bros. subjects (MarioWiki:Proposals/Archive_51#MarioWiki:Proposals/Archive_51#Smash_Bros._Articles:_What_Stays_and_What_Goes.3F)Time Turner (User:Time Turner)
April 9, 2018​
11.Decide how to cover recurring events in the Mario & Sonic series (https://www.mariowiki.com/MarioWiki:Proposals/Archive_52#Change_the_way_that_recurring_Mario_.26_Sonic_events_are_handled.2C_round_2)BBQ Turtle (User:BBQ Turtle)
July 17, 2018​
12.Allow ports of games with substantial new content to be split from the parent articles (https://www.mariowiki.com/MarioWiki:Proposals/Archive_52#Split_Switch.2F3DS_ports_with_substantial_new_content)Waluigi Time (User:Waluigi Time)
July 23, 2018​
13.Implement "See also" sections in Mario Party minigames and WarioWare series microgame articles (https://www.mariowiki.com/MarioWiki:Proposals/Archive_52#Implement_.22See_also.22_sections_in_Mario_Party_minigame_and_WarioWare_microgame_articles_for_related_mini.2Fmicrogames)Mechanical Dirge (User:Mechanical Dirge)
August 28, 2018​
14.Create an article on the 2015 Pixels film (https://www.mariowiki.com/MarioWiki:Proposals/Archive_52#Does_the_movie_Pixels_warrant_guest-appearance_coverage.3F)Glowsquid (User:Glowsquid)
September 12, 2018​
15.Consider Super Mario Land, Super Mario Land 2: 6 Golden Coins, Super Mario Maker, and Super Mario Run as part of the Super Mario series (https://www.mariowiki.com/MarioWiki:Proposals/Archive_52#Merge_Super_Mario_Land_series.2C_Super_Mario_Maker.2C_Super_Mario_Run_into_.22Super_Mario.22_series)CompliensCreator (User:CompliensCreator)
September 17, 2018​
16.Figure out how to classify Monty Mole and Rocky Wrench relative to each other (https://www.mariowiki.com/Talk:Rocky_Wrench#Reworking_Relations_Returns.21)Doc von Schmeltwick (User:Doc von Schmeltwick)
September 21, 2018​
17.Split Mike's Theme from Mike (https://www.mariowiki.com/Talk:Mike#Split_into_Mike_and_Mike.27s_Theme)Scrooge200 (User:Scrooge200)
September 22, 2018​

(remember to make sure to contact the user first before working on any proposal, if they are still active)

Personally, I want to see the 2015 DKC and DKL boss level article proposal get done.
 
You don't need to message me about my proposal--because I will say upfront I still think we need that Arcade Archives page. :P
 
Are you willing to have others work on it?
 
Baby Luigi said:
Are you willing to have others work on it?
Click to expand...
Well, I think that's kind of a given--I wouldn't have made it a proposal for others to contribute to if I was expecting to just work on the page all on my own. :???:
 
One of the rules says this

The original proposer must take action accordingly if the outcome of the proposal dictates it.

So I'm just making sure so we avoid accusations of edit-sniping.
 
I'll take Arcade Archives.
 
i'll say right now that my ttyd badges proposal was kinda half-baked as i don't really have the coding skills necessary to make such a template, and as the counterarguments went up for it i realized that their reasoning was pretty sound and mine was somewhat shaky. iirc it was also pretty divided proposal that one by only a few votes so if it needs to be like rescinded/overturned or whatever, its fine

of course if anyone can take care of it themselves they are perfectly free to and i wont accuse them of sniping, sorry for the inconvenience
 
Baby Luigi said:
Personally, I want to see the 2015 DKC and DKL boss level article proposal get done.
Click to expand...
Done the DKC(1) boss levels now. Might do DKL, but probably won't do the DKC2/3 or DKL2/3 ones any time soon - I had a convenient save file for DKC1, don't feel like playing entirely through all the other games just to do this!
 
Reboot said:
Baby Luigi said:
Personally, I want to see the 2015 DKC and DKL boss level article proposal get done.
Click to expand...
Done the DKC(1) boss levels now. Might do DKL, but probably won't do the DKC2/3 or DKL2/3 ones any time soon - I had a convenient save file for DKC1, don't feel like playing entirely through all the other games just to do this!
Click to expand...

There's also the Returns and Tropical Freeze levels.
 
I'll attempt to snap up the Mario Party 4 hosts proposal, though I'll contact Tails777 to see if he's interested in enacting it himself.
 
Updated list.

I'm interested in enacting the game ports split but I'm quite busy working on something else right now.
 
Updated list.

Probably thinking about tackling the Behemoth King article expansion. Will message Owencrazyboy9 about it.
 
Is the trimming of Fire creatures and Ice creatures complete? I've checked ice creatures, and it seems to be appropriate now. Haven't checked fire creatures, but haven't been paying attention there.
 
I seem to Doc von S. trimming the categories some time ago, my best bet would be to ask them.
 
Updated list.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back