My Little Pony Friendship is Magic

Favourite pony out of the main bunch?

  • Twilight Sparkle

    Votes: 25 16.7%

  • Pinkie Pie

    Votes: 28 18.7%

  • Applejack

    Votes: 13 8.7%

  • Rainbow Dash

    Votes: 31 20.7%

  • Rarity

    Votes: 18 12.0%

  • Fluttershy

    Votes: 35 23.3%
  • Total voters
    150
Nabber said:
okay what does the location matter?

Point is, I don't care who tells me what, I'm not trusting Criminal Joe after he trapped me in that prison cell.
Click to expand...
Really Nabber your going to ignore things the show itself set in stone like the ponies extreme loyalty to Princess C to the point where the don't dare disobey her, the fact that there was a literal celebration where luna was excepted back into society...also what the fuck why would she still speak in ye old yelling when shes been freed for months so she should have realized (from her own sister) that they no longer speak in ye old yelling. it doesn't make any fucking sense
 
Well, that is the traditional Canterlot voice (and she seems like the traditional type). And who said this is in chronological order?
 
Tyrannosaurus Debt said:
also what the fuck why would she still speak in ye old yelling when shes been freed for months so she should have realized (from her own sister) that they no longer speak in ye old yelling. it doesn't make any fucking sense
Click to expand...
Take someone with a foreign accent and place them in, say, the USA or Canada or someplace where their accent is out of place. In a few months, that someone will most likely still have accent. The same principle applies here.
 
Time Turner said:
Tyrannosaurus Debt said:
also what the fuck why would she still speak in ye old yelling when shes been freed for months so she should have realized (from her own sister) that they no longer speak in ye old yelling. it doesn't make any fucking sense
Click to expand...
Take someone with a foreign accent and place them in, say, the USA or Canada or someplace where their accent is out of place. In a few months, that someone will most likely still have accent. The same principle applies here.
Click to expand...
Yelling is not an accent (also i'm pretty sure she apologizes to Princess C in a normal voice.
Nabber said:
Well, that is the traditional Canterlot voice (and she seems like the traditional type). And who said this is in chronological order?
Click to expand...
So your trying to tell me that at no point did her oh so loving sister says something like "By the way we don't yell anymore"
 
Shoey, you often raise good points, but this is not one of those times.
Tyrannosaurus Debt said:
Time Turner said:
Tyrannosaurus Debt said:
also what the fuck why would she still speak in ye old yelling when shes been freed for months so she should have realized (from her own sister) that they no longer speak in ye old yelling. it doesn't make any fucking sense
Click to expand...
Take someone with a foreign accent and place them in, say, the USA or Canada or someplace where their accent is out of place. In a few months, that someone will most likely still have accent. The same principle applies here.
Click to expand...
Yelling is not an accent (also i'm pretty sure she apologizes to Princess C in a normal voice.
Nabber said:
Well, that is the traditional Canterlot voice (and she seems like the traditional type). And who said this is in chronological order?
Click to expand...
So your trying to tell me that at no point did her oh so loving sister says something like "By the way we don't yell anymore"
Click to expand...
well my oh so loving father told my sister that she shouldn't chew with her mouth open repeatedly but she still does it out of habit
also we've seen that Celestia is a petty troll.
 
Nabber said:
Shoey, you often raise good points, but this is not one of those times.
Tyrannosaurus Debt said:
Time Turner said:
Tyrannosaurus Debt said:
also what the fuck why would she still speak in ye old yelling when shes been freed for months so she should have realized (from her own sister) that they no longer speak in ye old yelling. it doesn't make any fucking sense
Click to expand...
Take someone with a foreign accent and place them in, say, the USA or Canada or someplace where their accent is out of place. In a few months, that someone will most likely still have accent. The same principle applies here.
Click to expand...
Yelling is not an accent (also i'm pretty sure she apologizes to Princess C in a normal voice.
Nabber said:
Well, that is the traditional Canterlot voice (and she seems like the traditional type). And who said this is in chronological order?
Click to expand...
So your trying to tell me that at no point did her oh so loving sister says something like "By the way we don't yell anymore"
Click to expand...
well my oh so loving father told my sister that she shouldn't chew with her mouth open repeatedly but she still does it out of habit
also we've seen that Celestia is a petty troll.
Click to expand...
I recall her doing one semi immoral thing (sending her sister to the moon) everything else from what I recall was people being worried about her visits and shit. Also from what I recall Nightmare moon continued to use the traditional speak because that's what she thought the royals still used
 
Nabber said:
Honestly, we're having an argument on why Luna was shouting, of all things.
Click to expand...
I'm sorry MLP writers are bad at remembering things (also any flash backs containing the royal family will be annoying as hell what with all the shouting)
 
Nabber said:
well Luna wasn't shouting in the Season 3 Premiere.

Does that make you happy?
Click to expand...
No for I've already decided not to watch it because it's a two parter therefore it must be terrible
 
Time Turner said:
Tyrannosaurus Debt said:
Nabber said:
well Luna wasn't shouting in the Season 3 Premiere.

Does that make you happy?
Click to expand...
No for I've already decided not to watch it because it's a two parter therefore it must be terrible
Click to expand...
I still don't quite understand why you think every two-parter is terrible.
Click to expand...
Because they are all been awful I think I've explained this multiple times
 
Nabber said:
Pokémon Trainer Toad85 said:
Nabber said:
Celestia is a petty troll.
Click to expand...

Since when, in canon, has Celestia acted this way?
Click to expand...
Ticketmaster.
Click to expand...
From what I remember she had no way of knowing that Twilights friends wanted to go and at the end she just gave her the tickets after Twilight told her she couldn't go if she could only bring one friend so explain to me where the petty troll part comes into play?
 
Well, in Luna Eclipsed, Luna's shouting is because that's how royalty talked in Equestria 1000 years ago, and even though times have changed, Celestia doesn't tell her.

This is kind of stretching it and Celestia isn't the only one to blame but no one bothered to listen to Twilight when she thought Cadence was acting strangely. When Cadence acts like a drama queen, the other ponies and Spike ignore Twilight and try to cheer up Cadence while Celestia walks by and tells Twilight that she has a lot to think about and of course Twilight was right all along. You'd think that any suspicions Twilight had would be plausible since she correctly predicted Nightmare Moon's return.
 
The Little Traitor Dudes For Children's Defense said:
Well, in Luna Eclipsed, Luna's shouting is because that's how royalty talked in Equestria 1000 years ago, and even though times have changed, Celestia doesn't tell her.

This is kind of stretching it and Celestia isn't the only one to blame but no one bothered to listen to Twilight when she thought Cadence was acting strangely. When Cadence acts like a drama queen, the other ponies and Spike ignore Twilight and try to cheer up Cadence while Celestia walks by and tells Twilight that she has a lot to think about and of course Twilight was right all along. You'd think that any suspicions Twilight had would be plausible since she correctly predicted Nightmare Moon's return.
Click to expand...
But it doesn't make any sense Princess C has been shown to clearly love her sister so why wouldn't she tell her that they no longer shout (or why didn't Luna realize that Princess C didn't shout any more)
 
My headcanon is that Luna just prefers talking in the antiquated Royal Canterlot Voice as opposed to modern English. :\
 
Pokémon Trainer Toad85 said:
My headcanon is that Luna just prefers talking in the antiquated Royal Canterlot Voice as opposed to modern English. :\
Click to expand...
But from what I recall she seems surprised when Twilight tells her that the yelling was scaring people which implies that she thought that royalty still used the traditional yelling voice
 
Pokémon Trainer Toad85 said:
Nabber said:
Pokémon Trainer Toad85 said:
Nabber said:
Celestia is a petty troll.
Click to expand...

Since when, in canon, has Celestia acted this way?
Click to expand...
Ticketmaster.
Click to expand...

late in the episode said:
My faithful student Twilight,
Why didn't you just say so in the first place?
Click to expand...

She didn't know that Twi kept all five of her friends.
Click to expand...
The whole point of the previous episode (the pilot) was that Twilight was supposed to study the magic of friendship. And that was what she was told to do at the end of the pilot.

And why would she expect Twilight to turn back on one of her friends after only one episode?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back