Tell a story to make the above user's avatar seems spooky!

[Teedgee]

A T-rex is already scary. No need to tell stories.

 

[The Nate]

buckberry (blue toad) killed mario and took his hat

 

[Teedgee]

This is a detached head.

 

[LeftyGreenMario]

Mario possessed that blue Toad and he's now ready to freak out Luigi by hiding in the dark, ambushing him, and saying, "You can't save here, Luigi; your memory card is full."

 

[Mario Kart DS Fan]

you are a fake princess, but just any fake princess, . yes, THE

 

[LeftyGreenMario]

BOO! That Boo amiibo made a well-placed jumpscare completely out of nowhere and made an unfortunate Luigi whiff badly on hole 18 of Bowser Badlands in Mario Golf: Toadstool Tour. Luigi otherwise would've had the gold trophy for the Bowser Championship and Luigi, who was cocky, didn't save. Bummer! Luigi now must redo the Championship!

 

[Sweet Snow]

The sky is pink in the background, that clearly a sign that Mario's world is being obliterated by Majin Buu but yet he still smiles, creepy.

 

[Teedgee]

aaah......?

 

[LeftyGreenMario]

This avatar has a voice that causes listeners' eardrums to explode.

 

[Mario Kart DS Fan]

you are kamek in disguise!

 

[Specific Neptune]

he watches me at night...his eyes never close, yet even though he's just a toy...i think i saw him blink...

 

[Teedgee]

He can crush you with a single finger... Do I need to say more?

 

[Sp00kDragon]

The red shows blood, meaning that the toad has killed many ppl

 

[Sp00kDragon]

Btw inside mouth is wat i meant

 

[Sweet Snow]

I suppose nuclear bombs are really not something you have to explain why they're scary, but the real scary part is that shade of yellow is just ugly, darling.

 

[J-Yoshi64]

That's a purple Unikitty instead of a pink one. She must be a ghost.

 

[Ray Trace]

The Yoshi form of the above user is actually a demon who possessed the above user. The user appears to be smiling to himself, lying that everything is okay when in actuality he's quite in deep internal pain and cannot express his true feelings. This is what Yoshi demons do to people: psychologically torment them until they cannot take it any more.

 

[LeftyGreenMario]

Your avatar is really what caused Vladimir Putin to go completely nuts and also rigged some helpful Russian bots to help useful idiots who are in the strategic districts in America.

 

[J-Yoshi64]

Mario is dressed like a bride. I don't know how to make that scarier.

 

[LeftyGreenMario]

He's likely responsible for some of the chicken deaths around the world!

 

[Teedgee]

Mario stole this dress from some lady after murdering her...

 

[Czario]

I was once playing Tennis with this Toad, and then I sprained my ankle! Oh, the horror!

 

[Sweet Snow]

Yo, what are you planning to do with those leaches?

 

[Teedgee]

Don't let this cuteness fool you! This Amy Rose-like character is a werewolf

 

[Noct]

Said Toad is actually Doopliss in disguise.